What Are The Best Jalapeños Substitutes?

If you’re looking for a tasty and spicy kick to your cooking, jalapeños are the perfect ingredient. And the flavors intensify ordinary meals into something with a unique kick everyone can love.

But if you’re sensitive to their heat level or just looking for something different, there are plenty of other great alternatives that can bring the same flavor and spice to your favorite dishes.

What Are The Best Jalapeños Substitutes

Read on for our list of the six best substitutes for jalapeños and more!

What Are Jalapeños?

Jalapeños are a unique type of chili pepper that adds an incredibly fresh flavor to Mexican cuisine. 

With a medium level of heat, they pack just enough punch to tantalize the taste buds without overpowering them. 

For those who want an even milder taste, jalapeños are often sold as pickles or can be dried for an intense flavor with a minimal amount of heat.

1. Serrano Peppers

Serrano peppers are tasty, medium-hot chili peppers that are perfect for adding a kick of heat to any dish. 

Often used as an alternative to jalapeños, they provide more heat than their mild counterpart and have an intense flavor.

However, if you’re looking for something similar but with a bit of extra punch, serranos are the way forward.

When it comes to appearance, serranos, and jalapeños share some similarities – both have green skins and protruding tips – but there is a distinguishable difference between the two peppers. 

Serranos tend to be smaller than jalapeño peppers with thinner walls, which can affect their suitability in certain recipes when substituting for the latter. 

Nevertheless, serranos remain a popular choice in Latin American cooking because of their potent flavor; just remember the added heat level!

2. Anaheim Peppers

Anaheim peppers are a type of medium-heat chili pepper popular in Mexican and Southwestern cuisine. 

They have a mild, slightly sweet flavor with thicker walls than jalapeño peppers, making them perfect for stuffing or sautéing. 

The Scoville scale gives Anaheim peppers a moderate heat between 500 and 5000 units, making them suitable for those who don’t want to add too much heat to their dishes. 

This makes them a great alternative to jalapeño peppers if you’re looking for something milder but still flavorful.

Anaheim peppers can be enjoyed in a variety of dishes; they are very versatile and can be used in salsas, on top of nachos and salads, stuffed, or pan-fried.

You can even use Anaheim peppers as an ingredient in marinades or sauces to add a little bit of spice. 

3. Fresno Peppers

Fresno peppers have a growing popularity in the culinary world due to their ability to provide the same heat level as a jalapeño, but with different flavors and aromas.

Fresno peppers are crisp, juicy, and smoky yet have an underlying fruity aroma. 

Some may confuse the mature red Fresno pepper with that of the red jalapeño, although it’s been said that Fresno is slightly spicier and packs more punch. 

If a milder version is desired, opt for the green Fresno peppers which feature thinner walls, resulting in less crunchiness accompanied by an earthy freshness. 

In relation to heat levels, Fresno peppers can measure between 2,500 and 10,000 units on the Scoville scale, which makes them an excellent choice for fiery salsas or tacos.

When cooking with these little gems, it’s important to note that you should use plastic gloves when handling them because of the spiciness; otherwise wash your hands diligently before using any other ingredient, especially if you’re intolerant to spice levels. 

Additionally, they don’t need high cooking temperatures, so they can be added last minute as a topping or to enhance flavor without spending too much time stirring them around

4. Cayenne Pepper Powder

Cayenne pepper powder is an ideal substitute for jalapeño peppers. Not only does it offer a powerful heat, but it is also ideal for those who don’t like the crunchy texture of jalapeño peppers. 

It has a score of 30,000 to 50,000 on the Scoville scale, making it about 12 times hotter than jalapeño peppers. 

If you find yourself in need of a jalapeño pepper substitute that provides more heat than jalapeños, then this could be what you are looking for.

One teaspoonful of cayenne pepper powder provides the same amount of heat as one jalapeño pepper; naturally, though, you can adjust the quantity to suit your own taste and dietary requirements. 

Many people opt to use more cayenne in their recipes unless they desire a super-hot kick with their meals and snacks. 

If you happen to run out of jalapeños, then cayenne could be an adequate alternative that adds heat without the crunchy texture and will likely give dishes the zest they have been lacking without having to compromise on flavor or nutritional content.

5. Smoked Paprika

Smoked paprika powder is a great alternative to add heat and spice to your dishes without the crunchiness of jalapeños. 

It comes in many varieties, ranging from milder versions (measuring 250 units on the Scoville scale) to spicier varieties (measuring up to 1000 units). 

This makes it easy for you to find an option that works best for your dish and palate.

When combined with bell peppers, smoked paprika will produce a delicious taste with different levels of heat – adding more flavor than simple jalapeños.

Not only is smoked paprika powder perfect for making salsa or soups, but it’s also great for giving marinades and rubs a distinctive smoky flavor. 

If you’re looking to give your meal an extra kick, try incorporating some smoked paprika as a garnish on top of your dish when finished; not only will this give it additional flavor, but also make it look stunning! 

In addition, if desired, this seasoning can be combined with other spices such as garlic powder or onion flakes.

Doing so will help enhance the overall taste of your dish while bringing out its unique depth and complexity.

6. Habanero Peppers

Habanero peppers are the hottest peppers on the market, boasting a Scoville units score of up to 445,000. 

This makes them more than 70 times hotter than jalapeño peppers, and they have a tropical, fruity flavor that you will not find in other types of pepper. 

Their color can range from bright green to orange, and they work as an excellent replacement for jalapeños in recipes such as nachos, salsa, or fruit-based sauces. 

A little Habanero goes a long way, so it’s best to only use small amounts at first until you can decide whether the flavor works for you without it becoming too spicy.

These peppers make an excellent addition to many dishes due to their unique flavor and heat level. 

Additionally, because Habanero peppers are high in antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals as well as capsaicin – which is believed to reduce inflammation – they also provide some health benefits too.

If stored correctly, these hot little gems will keep for up to two months in the refrigerator. 

Whether you’re looking for an extra kick of spice or just crave that fruity flavor inherent with habaneros, these peppers are certain to be your new favorite cooking ingredient!

Final Thoughts

Jalapeños are a popular ingredient in many dishes, but if you find yourself without them, there are plenty of alternatives that can provide the same heat and flavor. 

Cayenne pepper powder and smoked paprika are great options for adding a kick of spice to your dish without the crunchiness of jalapeño peppers. 

For those who prefer something even hotter, habanero peppers are up to 70 times hotter than jalapeños, making them an excellent choice for those seeking tropical flavor and intense heat.

What Are The Best Jalapeños Substitutes?

Recipe by AubreyCourse: Substitutes


Prep time


Cooking time





What are the best jalapeños substitutes out there, and what do you need to know about them? Let’s dive into our article all about jalapeños substitutes.


  • Serrano Peppers

  • Anaheim Peppers

  • Fresno Peppers

  • Cayenne Pepper Powder

  • Smoked Paprika

  • Habanero Peppers


  • Decide on what substitute you need
  • Pick a substitute from the list above
  • Read what you need to substitute with
  • Create the recipe and enjoy
Scroll to Top